Best Car Insurance in Pittsburgh, PA
Looking for car Insurance in Pittsburgh? Below you'll find 10 local options with their address, phone number, website and opening hours, plus practical advice on choosing the right one.
What they do: Insurance agencies that sell auto coverage. Pennsylvania requires liability and first-party medical benefits and lets drivers choose between limited tort and full tort, which affects your right to sue after an accident.
This guide lists 10 car Insurance in and around Pittsburgh, spread across 10 ZIP codes. 10 have a phone number you can call directly from this page, 10 link to their own website, 4 are open on weekends. Listings are organized so you can compare them at a glance and contact them directly.
Top 10 Car Insurance in Pittsburgh
Listings are shown in no paid order: no business can pay to appear or to rank higher on this page.
1 Murray Insurance Services
- Address 1565 McFarland Rd, Pittsburgh, PA 15216
- Phone (412) 561-1600
- Website murrayinsuranceagency.com
Opening hours
| Mon | 8 AM-6 PM |
|---|---|
| Tue | 8 AM-6 PM |
| Wed | 8 AM-6 PM |
| Thu | 8 AM-6 PM |
| Fri | 8 AM-6 PM |
| Sat | 10 AM-4 PM |
| Sun | Closed |
2 Bob Shanahan - GEICO Insurance Agent
- Address 3463 William Penn Hwy, Pittsburgh, PA 15235
- Phone (412) 317-5500
- Website geico.com
Opening hours
| Mon | 9 AM-7 PM |
|---|---|
| Tue | 9 AM-7 PM |
| Wed | 9 AM-7 PM |
| Thu | 9 AM-7 PM |
| Fri | 9 AM-6 PM |
| Sat | 10 AM-3 PM |
| Sun | Closed |
3 Darla Zeli - State Farm Insurance Agent
- Address 2513 E Carson St, Pittsburgh, PA 15203
- Phone (412) 431-7166
- Website darlazeli.net
Opening hours
| Mon | 9 AM-5 PM |
|---|---|
| Tue | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Wed | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Thu | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Fri | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Sat | Closed |
| Sun | Closed |
4 Brown Insurance Agency
- Address 213 Smithfield St suite 207, Pittsburgh, PA 15222
- Phone (412) 681-7114
- Website brown4insurance.com
Opening hours
| Mon | 9 AM-5 PM |
|---|---|
| Tue | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Wed | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Thu | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Fri | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Sat | Closed |
| Sun | Closed |
5 Mike Newell - State Farm Insurance Agent
- Address 4772 Liberty Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15224
- Phone (412) 621-0600
- Website mikenewell.biz
Opening hours
| Mon | 9 AM-5 PM |
|---|---|
| Tue | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Wed | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Thu | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Fri | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Sat | Closed |
| Sun | Closed |
6 McElhinny Insurance Agency LLC
- Address 5624 Brownsville Rd Second Floor, Pittsburgh, PA 15236
- Phone (412) 650-5700
- Website mcelhinny.com
Opening hours
| Mon | 9 AM-5 PM |
|---|---|
| Tue | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Wed | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Thu | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Fri | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Sat | 9 AM-12 PM |
| Sun | Closed |
7 Coleman Insurance
- Address 945 Perry Hwy, Pittsburgh, PA 15237
- Phone (412) 366-9465
- Website colemanautoinsurance.com
Opening hours
| Mon | 9 AM-5 PM |
|---|---|
| Tue | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Wed | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Thu | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Fri | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Sat | Closed |
| Sun | Closed |
8 Megan Chicone - State Farm Insurance Agent
- Address 200 Hightower Blvd #405, Pittsburgh, PA 15205
- Phone (412) 489-5060
- Website chiconeinsurance.com
Opening hours
| Mon | 9 AM-5 PM |
|---|---|
| Tue | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Wed | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Thu | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Fri | 9 AM-3:30 PM |
| Sat | Closed |
| Sun | Closed |
9 James L Smith Insurance Agency
- Address 304 Cochran Rd, Pittsburgh, PA 15228
- Phone (412) 531-3111
- Website jlsins.net
Opening hours
| Mon | 9 AM-5 PM |
|---|---|
| Tue | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Wed | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Thu | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Fri | 9 AM-3 PM |
| Sat | Closed |
| Sun | Closed |
10 T Rankin - State Farm Insurance Agent
- Address 838 Western Ave Suite 1, Pittsburgh, PA 15233
- Phone (412) 322-1064
- Website trankinsfinsurance.com
Opening hours
| Mon | 9 AM-7 PM |
|---|---|
| Tue | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Wed | 9 AM-5 PM |
| Thu | 9 AM-7 PM |
| Fri | 9 AM-4 PM |
| Sat | 10 AM-2 PM |
| Sun | Closed |
How to choose car Insurance in Pittsburgh
- Check any required licenses or certifications for the profession in Pennsylvania.
- Ask for references from clients with needs similar to yours.
- Get pricing in writing, whether hourly, flat-fee or retainer.
- Make sure you know who will actually handle your account or project.
- Compare response times. A quick reply before you hire usually means good service afterwards.
Local tips for Pittsburgh
Allegheny County's Health Department licenses plumbers throughout the county and inspects restaurants, and the City of Pittsburgh's Department of Permits, Licenses and Inspections handles building permits and contractor licensing inside city limits.
Because of the rivers and hills, a business that looks close on a map can be a long drive away. Check which side of the river it's on and whether a bridge or tunnel stands in the way, especially at rush hour.
Pittsburgh is in Allegheny County, and local phone numbers use the 412 and 878 area codes. Popular areas include Downtown, Strip District, Lawrenceville, Shadyside, Squirrel Hill, Oakland, South Side, North Shore.
Frequently asked questions
Which car Insurance in Pittsburgh are open on weekends?
According to their listed hours, these are open on Saturday or Sunday: Murray Insurance Services, Bob Shanahan - GEICO Insurance Agent, McElhinny Insurance Agency LLC, T Rankin - State Farm Insurance Agent. Hours can change on holidays, so call before you go.
Which areas of Pittsburgh do these car Insurance cover?
The car Insurance on this list are located in ZIP codes 15203, 15205, 15216, 15222, 15224, 15228, 15233, 15235, 15236, 15237. Many businesses also serve nearby neighborhoods and suburbs, so ask when you call.
How do I compare car Insurance in Pittsburgh?
Shortlist two or three providers, ask each for a written proposal with pricing and scope, check reviews and references, and choose the one that communicates most clearly.
Is it better to hire a local provider?
A local provider knows Pittsburgh's market and regulations and can meet in person, which helps with complex or ongoing work.
What questions should I ask before hiring?
Ask about experience with similar clients, total cost, timelines, who your contact will be, and how problems or disputes are handled.
Car Insurance in other Pennsylvania cities
More professional services guides in Pittsburgh
Information is collected from public sources and may change. Please confirm hours, prices and availability directly with each business. Business owner? Ask us to update your listing.